• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Simply old thyme recipes

Family recipes reimagined

simplyoldthymerecipes@gmail.com

BBQ Beef Patties

August 21, 2016 by simplyoldthymerecipes@gmail.com Leave a Comment

BBQ Beef Patties

“Moist & tender burgers baked in a tangy BBQ sauce”

BBQ Beef Patties

 

This recipe looked like it was clipped from a local cookbook, that included the main dish and 2 side dishes. Originally I was going to use a homemade thick barbecue sauce my mother used to make, but once I looked over the recipe the simplicity of the dish intrigued me. I decided to follow the recipe pretty closely only making a few minor changes. The beef patties turned out moist and tender and the sauce was a great compliment to the burgers. Image small individual meatloaves when you think of this recipe.

Any time I use ground beef, or really any cut of meat, I think of a story my father told me about his grandfather whom had passed on long before I was born. He told me many stories about my great-grandfather. The story that has always stood out in my mind has alway been how my great-grandfather stopped eating beef.

My great-grand father was born in the late 1800’s, long before the great depression. He always lived a simple life. He had a big garden and worked in the coal mine. My grandparents had lived with my great-grandparents since they were first married. From my understanding, great-grandpa ate all the staples of the time. Including every kind of beef and pork imaginable.

One day while helping the local butcher process a cow, how do I say this nicely, the cow was pregnant. From that day on he refused to eat beef. He couldn’t get that experience out of his mind. This was not an easy task for my grandmother who did most of the cooking. Ground beef was a staple, inexpensive, and an easy ingredient for dinner back in that day. So she would have to make 2 separate main dishes usually some kind of pork, mostly in the form of bacon for my great-grandfather.

One day when the family had gathered for dinner my grandmother had made hamburger patties for dinner. Of course bacon was on the menu for her father (my great-grandfather) who was in the later years of his life. While every one was eating he looked up and said I think I’ll have one of those sausage patties, so my grandmother place one of the beef patties on his plate. Everyone was looking at him with their eyes wide open with amazement, especially since no one had seen him eat beef in years.

He finished the patty and looked at my grandmother and said “that is the best sausage patty I’ve every had. And I think I’ll have another.” My grandmother without skipping a beat picked up another patty and place it on his plate and said “Yes it is.”Everyone laughed to themselves and as far as I know that was the last time he had every eaten a piece of beef.

I hope you enjoy the beef patties, they are wonderfully moist and flavorful.

Also extremely quick and easy to make for dinner.

Enjoy

BBQ Beef Patties

Moisten bread crumbs with milk

BBQ Beef Patties

Combine with ground beef salt & pepper

BBQ Beef Patties

Gently mix

BBQ Beef Patties

Form into 4 patties

(the picture is a half recipe)

BBQ Beef Patties

Combine sauce ingredients

BBQ Beef Patties

Pour over patties

BBQ Beef Patties

Bake and enjoy!!

BBQ Beef Patties

BBQ Beef Patties

Filed Under: Main Course Tagged With: BBQ Beef patties

Fettuccine Toss

July 18, 2016 by simplyoldthymerecipes@gmail.com Leave a Comment

Fettuccine Toss

“Chicken & bell peppers tossed with fettuccine in a white wine sauce”

Fettuccine toss

This is a recipe from my wife’s family which has become a go to recipe for us over the years. Mainly because it’s so easy to prepare and tastes out of this world. I have made many changes to this recipe over the past several years and this has been the end result which is absolutely amazing. It’s easy to make on any night of the week when time is short. Also there are many ways to change it up to meet your needs or likings. You could change the chicken for shrimp which my mother-in-law does quiet frequently. Change the type of pasta- whole wheat pasta, gluten free pasta, and so on. In the following pictures I used linguini since I was out of fettuccini. Another change could be to add different vegetables instead of or along with the bell peppers. Just let your imagination run wild and see what you come up with.

I’m not sure exactly where this recipe came from but I do know the reason why my mother-in-law made this recipe. Many years ago when my wife was a little girl she had went with her family to SeaWorld. There she remembers eating a very greasy hamburger. She just didn’t feel right after eating the burger. She became increasingly more ill as time passed while at SeaWorld. After being violently sick for twelve hours straight my wife ended  up in the ER.  The doctors had many test done with no answer to why she was so ill. Finally they called in a gastroenterologist. There he diagnosed her with pancreatitis. The gastroenterologist told her she was one of youngest he had ever had with this. She had to be on an extremely low fat diet so she could recover and get back to normal. Thats where this recipe fits in. The original recipe was extremely low in fat and healthy.

My recipe still stays true to the recipe in terms of how healthy this dish is overall. To make it even more healthy and low in fat you can substitute whole wheat pasta and use all olive oil instead of the butter. Also if you don’t want to use wine you could use chicken stock, but in my opinion the wine just adds so much more flavor to the overall dish. Like I said above this recipe has gone through many different variations until I came up with this final recipe that has become my go to pasta dish when we are in the mood for something healthy. I still switch up some of the ingredients depending on what I have in the fridge of fresh from the garden.

I hope you enjoy this quick, simple, & healthy recipe and can share this with your family.

Enjoy!!!

Fettuccine toss

Brown chicken in butter & olive oil

Fettuccine toss

Remove chicken and cook onions, peppers & garlic

Fettuccine toss

Add wine and herbs

Fettuccine toss

Add chicken back to pan

Fettuccine toss

Toss pasta to combine

Fettuccine toss

Serve topped with parmesan cheese (freshly grated if you have it) and fresh parsley

Fettuccine toss

Fettuccine toss

Filed Under: Main Course, Pasta Tagged With: Fettuccini toss

Coffee Cake

May 18, 2016 by simplyoldthymerecipes@gmail.com Leave a Comment

Coffee Cake

Coffee Cake

“A moist crumb cake spiced with cinnamon, brown sugar, & pecans”

I found this recipe buried deep in one of my grandmothers cookbooks. It took me a while to make this recipe simply because I already had a pretty good recipe for coffee cake of my own. That was until one day I was sitting with my father going over some of the recipes I had found, but didn’t know who the names were on the recipes. This was a fascinating conversation. My father, the wonderful story teller, was remicining about the past. I got a lot of family information from that talk. He told me stories about my grandmother, our family, & family friends from his home town that I didn’t know until that day.

I asked him about this coffee cake recipe that had the name of Wilma on it. I could not place the name Wilma. When I asked dad who Wilma was he said “You know who that is. She’s the one who did the apolstry for us.” Then it hit me, I did know exactly who that was! I will never forget the first time I met her. It was when she was recovering my wife’s vanity stool in a purple fabric. We went to her house to pick out the fabric and to take her the stool. We walked in to her “little shop” aka her garage in the back of her house. The shop was like walking in to Batman’s dark lair and cluttered like a hoarder. This women was a spitfire! Wilma told you how it was without holding back, yet she was a sweet and kind person that would have done anything for anybody. The one thing that stuck out in my mind was the hay that she had stuck in her hair, not sure why or if she even knew it was there. I remember her talking to us and I couldn’t concentrate because I kept staring at the hay. It was definitely a memorable experience. The main thing I remembered about Wilma was her WHITE CAKE.

Now, I have an ongoing debate with my wife all the time about which is better, cake or pie.  She LOVES pie & I LOVE cake! Don’t get me wrong, I like pie or really anything sweet, but cake is by far my favorite. Especially really good white cake. I don’t really like chocolate cake because I think it can be a bit dry. But white cake that is done right is the best ever! I could eat it every day! The problem I have with cake is I can’t stop eating it. I slice it and think to myself that isn’t straight so I cut off a little more. Then it still isn’t straight so I cut off a little more. It can go on for a while until I realize I need to stop because there is no room on my plate for any more.

Back to Wilma’s cake, the reason I thought about her cake is because she made the best white cake I have ever eaten. It was moist yet dense and delicious. My parents would always get one of Wilma’s cakes for my birthday. Dad would call down and order it and she would leave it on her front porch for him to pick up. I have no idea how she made her cakes but I have never had anything like a cake from Wilma.

This coffee cake is moist and has a wonderful flavor. It has two layers of cinnamon streusel, one on top and one in the middle. I’m going to be honest here, the first time I made this recipe my wife told me it was good but the cake was missing something. I did take this with a grain of salt considering my wife doesn’t care for cake. However, I thought about it for a while and decided to try a mixture of confectioners sugar and water to make a glaze that I usually use for my scones. I have to admit that this small little mixture made all the difference. I just drizzled some on each slice but you could drizzle over the entire cake and let it set up before serving.

I hope you enjoy this recipe and get a little bit of wilma’s personality from this cake.

Enjoy!!!!

Coffee Cake

Grease & flour a bundt pan with removable bottom

Coffee Cake

Combine dry ingredients

Coffee Cake

Cream butter and sugar

Coffee Cake

Add Eggs and vanilla

Coffee Cake

Add dry ingredients and mix until just combined

Coffee Cake

In a separate bowl combine streusel ingredients

Coffee Cake

Spread half batter in prepared pan

Coffee Cake

Sprinkle half of the streusel mixture

Coffee Cake

Spread remaining batter

Coffee Cake

Sprinkle with rest of the streusel

Coffee Cake

Bake 350 degrees for about 60 minutes

Coffee Cake

Enjoy!!!

Coffee Cake

Filed Under: Cakes

Johnny Marzetti

April 30, 2016 by simplyoldthymerecipes@gmail.com 2 Comments

Johnny Marzetti

“A delicious and simple meal made with elbow macaroni & ground beef in tomato juice sauce”

IMG_5497

Johnny marzetti is a common dinner dish from the area I live. The original recipe when it was first served here in Columbus, Ohio was at Marietta’s Restaurant. It consisted of ground beef with tomato sauce, onion, mushrooms, macaroni and topped with cheddar cheese and baked into a casserole. There are a lot of variations of this dish, for instance my wife’s family uses egg noodles and topped it with velveta cheese. The variation I’m used to in my family usually consists of  elbow macaroni with ground beef in a tomato juice sauce, very simple and easy. I have found this can be somewhat bland simply because there just isn’t much in it. I found 3 different recipes in my grandmothers and great aunts collections. These recipes all had various different ingredients but the main ingredients were pretty much the same.

Remembering back to my mothers recipe she used to make, I decided to try a few changes of my own. First I made it with half ground beef and half sausage, just to add an extra layer of flavor. Another change I made was adding garlic along with the onions again for more flavor. I don’t usually keep tomato juice in the house on a regular basis, for this reason I ended up using whole peeled tomatoes since they were canned in tomato juice.

I stayed true to the johnny marzetti I was familiar with that my mother made by using elbow macaroni which is also used in the original recipe. The final dish had great flavor and reminded me a lot of my childhood. I hope you enjoy my version of Johnny Marzetti.

Also check out the original recipe at the link below:

http://ohiothoughtsblog.blogspot.com/2013/03/johnny-marzetti-recipe-and-history.html

It is wonderful and much different than my recipe. I highly recommend trying out both and maybe even come up with your own variation and share your favorite with future generation of your family.

Enjoy!!

IMG_5466

Gather your ingredients, I don’t have the worcestshire sauce bottle because I added it after the pic

IMG_5471

Brown meat, then remove and drain fat

IMG_5482

Saute onions, pepper, celery, garlic in butter and olive oil

IMG_5483

add dried herbs

IMG_5488

add water and juice and tomatoes

IMG_5489

add browned beef

IMG_5491

add (uncooked) macaroni and parsley and worcheshire sauce

IMG_5493

cover, reduce to simmer until pasta is tender

IMG_5497

Serve and enjoy!!!!!!!

Filed Under: Main Course

Banana Nut Bread (basic recipe)

April 23, 2016 by simplyoldthymerecipes@gmail.com Leave a Comment

Banana Nut Bread

“A great banana bread made without eggs”

Banana nut bread

One day I arrived home from work and felt like baking something sweet to surprise my wife when she came home. I didn’t have a lot in the house in the way of sweets. I started flipping through the “sweet recipe” scrapbooks I had made from my grandmothers recipes. I looked through the one with cakes and decided I just didn’t have that much time to bake and frost a cake. I looked through the random desserts, nothing jumped out at me. Then came the cookie book and again I had none of the ingredients in the house. As I was closing that scrapbook I looked over and saw 3 very ripe bananas. Now I’m very particular about the bananas I eat. My wife gives me a hard time because I only like bananas that have a little green and absolutely NO brown on them at all. These bananas had been on my counter for a while and were long past the point of peeling and eating. So it hit me, BANANA NUT BREAD!!!!! 

It would be easy, I had all the ingredients, and it is one of my wife’s favorites. As you can tell I try to be a good husband when I can. I had made a scrapbook for breads, as the pages turned there was no banana nut bread recipe. I thought how can that be, their has to be at least one recipe. I started to turn each page slowly and look closer at each recipe and finally found a very faded, small and hard to read recipe for what looked like banana nut bread.

I looked at it and decided I would give it a try. So I gathered all the ingredient and started. I know my grandmother would make this recipe with walnuts because that was what she loved to bake with and eat. I’m not a big fan of walnuts, for really no particular reason, I just prefer pecans. Any kind of nuts would work great in this recipe so feel free to use your favorite.

As I started a couple thing stood out as strange in the recipe. First off there were no instructions other than the ingredient list and how long to bake it for. Then I noticed that it called for only 1 tbsp of shorting which seemed like an extremely small amount of fat in the recipe. I’m used to making sweet breads with at least one stick of butter. I wanted to try and stay true to the recipe as much as possible, so I decided to increase the shortening to 2 tbsp. Then there was no salt, no spices and no vanilla. I added a pinch of salt, some fresh grated nutmeg, and a splash of vanilla extract.

I mixed the ingredients like I normally would for a recipe like this and poured into a greased loaf pan. Into the oven it went. Then all of a sudden, the light bulb went off, I realized there was an important ingredient missing!!!!! I double checked the recipe and realized I didn’t forget the eggs, it wasn’t written in the ingredients list. I thought it has to be a mistake that grandma must have forgotten to write it down. It was to late to do anything about it so I waited patiently while the bread bake. When the timer went off I tested it with a toothpick and removed it from the oven to cool.

The bread looked like every other recipe for banana nut bread. However, I was really anxious to see what the inside looked like, after all I have seen and eaten some beautiful food that tasted terrible. When the loaf was sliced, I was extremely surprised, it looked great! After dinner my wife had a piece and loved it, she said it tasted great. I still to this day have a hard time understanding why this recipe  works so well with out eggs and such a small amount of fat but it does. I guess I shouldn’t worry about it and just enjoy the simplicity of this recipe.

Enjoy!!!!!

banana nut bread ingredients

Mash bananas

banana nut bread mashed bananas

Combine dry ingredients

Banana nut bread dry ingredients

mix sugar and shortening

banana nut bread sugar shortening

add dry ingredients and bananas

banana nut bread with bananas

fold in vanilla and pecans

banana nut bread with pecans

pour into prepared pan

banana nut bread in pan

bake until golden brown!!!!

banana nut bread loaf

banana nut bread sliced

Filed Under: Breads

Double chocolate brownies

April 12, 2016 by simplyoldthymerecipes@gmail.com Leave a Comment

Double chocolate brownies

“Rich & gooey brownies with a flakey top”

IMG_5384

Every year my wife’s side of the family gets together to celebrate each birthday. For the last couple years I have been in charge of bringing dessert. This all started when I made a chocolate cheesecake for her grandmothers birthday. That may have been the best cake I have ever made, even to this day. It was a three layer cake: it had a entire cheesecake sandwiched between two layers of devils food chocolate cake, frosted with a chocolate fudge icing. This icing was made from whipping chocolate ganache into a lusciously smooth frosting. It was an unbelievable cake and her grandmother absolutely loved it.  She exclaimed to me that she had never had anything like it in her life. So ever since that day I’ve had a hard time trying to make any of my desserts live up to that cake.

This year we went up for dinner, no birthday to celebrate, just a time to get together and spend time with family. I decided to make brownies. Now anytime I think something is going to be easy or simple it has a way of turning into a much more involved process than expected.

I’ve made brownies many times before and even have come up with a few recipes of my own. One in particular had mini marshmallows in the batter, which I thought was a unique ingredient. That will be a recipe for another time. All those recipes usually had something else to them either frosting of some sort or cookie dough topping, just to name a few.

I wanted to come up with a recipe for basic brownies that would be rich and gooey and also easy to make. Also they needed to taste great just by themselves. I looked through my grandparents recipes and their cookbooks and surprisingly found a few brownie recipes. None of which sounded special in anyway. I decide to combine my grandmothers recipes with some of my ideas for a brownie recipe.

I finally came up with this recipe and it was incredible! It was rich, gooey and melt in your mouth delicious. It also had the most important characteristic of all…………a flakey top!

Now, the reason that a flakey top is the most important feature for my brownies is because when I was growing up my brothers and I would judge our mothers brownies on wether or not they had a flakey top. The brownies with a flakey top were the best! The ones that didn’t have a flakey top were not liked and my brother even refused to eat them. In a sense I became a brownie aficionado.

I decided to top this brownie recipe with a caramel sauce and flaked sea salt called Fleur de Sel just for an extra special touch. You can use any caramel sauce from the store. I made my own which I will post later. These brownies were a hit with my wife’s family.

These brownies would be wonderful by themselves or even with a scoop of vanilla ice cream.

Enjoy!!!

IMG_5353

Melt Butter and chocolate over a pot of simmering water (double boiler).

IMG_5359

In a separate bowl combine sugar and eggs.

IMG_5367

Add melted chocolate mixture to sugar and eggs

IMG_5373

Stir dry  ingredients just until combined

IMG_5378

In a separate bowl combine flour with chocolate chips

IMG_5371

Add to batter and spread in prepared pan

IMG_5380

Bake and cool.

IMG_5383

Serve with your choice of topping & Enjoy!!!!

IMG_5387

IMG_5394

Filed Under: Brownies/Bars

Hot Rolls

April 4, 2016 by simplyoldthymerecipes@gmail.com Leave a Comment

Hot Rolls

Grandma’s Dinner Rolls

Light, fluffy, and moist with a perfect texture just like grandma used to make!!

IMG_5650

Dinner rolls or “hot rolls” as they may also be know are a must have for any dinner table where I’m from. Every family has a special dinner roll recipe that graces the table on every special holiday dinner and most times during weekly dinner if time permits.

These rolls bring me right back to my childhood!! When I was growing up all of my grandparents lived less than 30 minutes from our house. My mom’s mother lived the closest and would come to our house every Tuesday, as long as she didn’t have special events going on at her church. It was a great time! She would usually come late morning or early afternoon and spend most of the day, help mom with dinner and just spend quality time with me. She would bring something for dessert, usually donuts, which is a story for another time!!!! She would also bring her homemade hot rolls and bake them right before dinner. There was nothing in this world like them! They were light and fluffy, had a great buttery flavor, nicely browned on top and not one bit dry. She would bring them Tuesday after Tuesday after Tuesday after Tuesday……………….if you haven’t caught my drift they got a little old after all those years. Just like anything, else if you have to much of anything it can get boring.

My Grandmother passed away right after I had graduated high school. For the longest time I really didn’t think much about these rolls since I was going to college, getting a job, and marrying the love of my life. When ever I thought of grandma these hot rolls always came to mind. I never came across a dinner roll that reminded me of her recipe. Once I started this project of organizing the family  recipes, I thought for sure I could find the recipe for her rolls. But like many things in life this was not as easy as I thought. I found 6 different dinner roll recipes, 3 of which I knew where her recipes, being that they were in her handwriting. The other 3, I didn’t know who they belonged to. Two of her recipes where incomplete and the other one just didn’t turn out right.

So I was back at square one on my search for grandmas hot rolls.

I looked through cookbooks, on websites, and even double and triple checked my familys’ recipes and couldn’t find one that was satisfying to me. Finally, I took all the recipes and re-read over each one carefully and started working out a hot roll recipe. After a couple attempts, the hot rolls I remembered all those years ago where born out of the oven in my very own kitchen.

Now, these rolls aren’t exactly as I remember her’s, but every time I bite into one it transports me back to my youth. The first time I made these for my family, it was Easter and I made 2 batches (30 rolls). We had 10 people for dinner that Easter and every roll disappeared. People were even wanting more.

The great thing about this recipe is that it uses fast rise yeast which really speeds up the process. Also they are easy to make a day ahead of time. All you have to do is refrigerate overnight after the final rise. Then the next day set the rolls out and let rise to room temp about 2 to 3 hours. Then bake as normal.

I highly recommend that you use a stand mixer like a kitchenmaid, which my grandmothers’ is still going strong and it has to be about 25 years + old. You can knead by hand but if you have a stand mixer you might as well use it.

The one suggestion I will make is after you divide the dough into the individual roll portions, the easiest way to shape them is to take one roll portion of dough. Flatten it under the palm of your hand. After flattening slowly, while still moving hand in a circular motion, bring your finger tips to the board. Increase the speed of the circular motion of your hand until your hand forms a cage around the ball of dough and is moving around to form a perfect ball.

It is kind of hard to explain but this link to Father Dominic, which I saw on PBS, explains it much better than I can. Check this link out before starting this recipe it will save you tons of time.                                                                                                                 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sVeFJEbodko

Enjoy!

IMG_5599

Combine the wet ingredients

IMG_5602

Stir in instant yeast

IMG_5604

and part of the flour

IMG_5605

Using a dough hook slowly add remaining flour

IMG_5606

This is what do will look like after combined

IMG_5608

At the end of the kneading time this is what you have

IMG_5609

Let rest

IMG_5610

Will double in size

IMG_5614

Divide into 15 pieces. (I divided mine into more by accident so I add the smaller ones together)

IMG_5615

Brush with melted butter and cover and let rise

(This is where, after the final rise, you could refrigerate overnight and set out about 2 hours before baking if making ahead)

IMG_5617

Right out of the oven

IMG_5642

Brushed with melted butter

IMG_5645

Viola!! a perfect dinner roll

IMG_5655

These rolls are perfect with just butter but you could add jelly, jams, apple butter etc…… anything you could think of .

Filed Under: Breads

Old Fashioned Meatloaf “The best ever”

April 2, 2016 by simplyoldthymerecipes@gmail.com Leave a Comment

Old Fashioned Meatloaf

“The Best Ever”

Super moist and delicious with a thick tomato meat sauce

IMG_5150

This is absolutely the best and most surprising meatloaf recipe ever! Now I grew up in southeastern Ohio eating meatloaf, the traditional way, with ketchup slathered on top of a mostly dry loaf of meat. Not the most edible thing. One day while sorting through some of grandmas main dish recipes I realized she had 3 separate and totally different recipes for meatloaf. At first I was a little apprehensive to make a meatloaf, especially one of these recipes. The last couple meatloaf recipes I made seemed to turn somewhat dry. My wife NEVER let me forget the turkey meatloaf I made many years ago that has been a sore point for both of us. I thought the turkey meatloaf turned out pretty good, but she still insists to this day that it wasn’t totally done in the middle. I kept telling her it was but I ended up putting it back in the oven and needless to say it didn’t have a drop of moisture any where to be found and was pretty darn dry when it came back out of the oven. Anyway my wife and I will continue to have different options about that for the rest of our marriage. Back to the 3 meatloaf recipes, one was your traditional meatloaf, the one that I was used to growing up with the ketchup on top which didn’t seem to exciting to me. Another one called for carrots, celery and cabbage ground! I think it was to be ground with the meat. Since I wasn’t going to grind my own meat I decided to look at the third recipe. That recipe seemed interesting because it didn’t have ketchup instead it was topped with tomato sauce and other ingredients including vinegar and brown sugar.

So I started to make this meatloaf one sunday afternoon that my wife had taken the kids to a birthday party.  I have to tell you that week I watched an episode of the barefoot contessa on food network and she had someone on that made a meatloaf that included panko bread crumbs and milk. With this in the back of my mind I looked over the recipe and decided to saute the onions and garlic in olive oil until softened. I went to grab Panko breadcrumbs from the pantry only to find out I was fresh out. Reluctantly I decided to use regular italian bread crumbs and added a little milk to help with moisture. I mixed all the rest of the ingredients just as the recipe had called for and formed it into a loaf. I place it in a glass loaf pan that had belonged to my grandmother just to help with the authenticity of the dish. Then I combined the ingredients for the topping. I was ready to pour over and realized it didn’t call for any salt. I took a taste and boy I was glad I did. It was sooooooo bland when the pinch of salt was added it made all the difference. I thought to myself, well there was a big disaster averted. Then I poured the sauce over the meatloaf and with my eyes bulging and my jaw hitting the ground I thought what have I done. The meatloaf disappeared under the red liquid. First I thought should I remove some of the tomato sauce, or should I start over. I took a deep breathe and decided to trust the recipe and put it in the oven with my fingers crossed, just for good measure.

Well, I was a little worried for the 1 hour and 15 minutes it was baking I kept checking on it as it baked away, and each time a little bit of the liquid was evaporating and I was slowly starting to see the top of the meat. When I removed the pan from the oven and allowed to rest for 15 minutes I was super surprised with what I found. After removing the entire meatloaf from the pan I was left with a thick meat sauce that was the perfect topping for this meatloaf. It was wonderfully moist and just melted in our mouths. My wife kept going on about how wonderful it was and I played it real cool by saying it turned out just as I had expected.

I hope you find this recipe as wonderful as we did since it has become my go to meatloaf recipe. Now the argument will continue to go on about the turkey meatloaf but for this one I’m happy to say we both will agree it is the best meatloaf either of us have ever tasted.

Enjoy!

IMG_5082

Saute onions and garlic in oil

IMG_5091

combine ingredients for topping

IMG_5097

Combine ingredients for meatloaf

IMG_5102

Gently mix together

IMG_5108

Place in loaf pan

IMG_5109

Now this is where you have to trust me and pour ALL of the topping over the meatloaf

IMG_5112

Bake then remove loaf from pan

IMG_5143

IMG_5146

Pour sauce over meatloaf and devour!!

I know what your thinking this is just another meatloaf recipe, but trust me this is by far one of the most wonderful meatloaf recipes I’ve ever had and even my wife is still going on and on and on about how this is the best meatloaf she’s ever had and I’ve told you she not an easy person to impress with meatloaf. I hope you enjoy and can share this recipe with your family for many years to come.

IMG_5149

Filed Under: Main Course

Jailhouse Cake

March 29, 2016 by simplyoldthymerecipes@gmail.com Leave a Comment

“Jailhouse Cake” aka Oat cake

A wonderful and easy cake spiced with cinnamon and a caramel coconut topping

Jailhouse cake

When my search through my grandmothers family recipes began, I was a little overwhelmed. The recipes where put in my house as storage. There were a ton of every kind of recipe you could image. As I was going through them my dad kept asking me if I had found a recipe for “jailhouse cake”. I told him no but would keep an eye out for it. Little did I know what kind of an undertaking that would be! I looked through family cookbook after family cookbook and didn’t see any cake by the name “jailhouse cake”. My father was relentless! Asking me every time I saw him or talk on the phone about grandma’s “Jailhouse cake” recipe. Finally, becoming exasperated, I asked him to describe the cake. He said it was a sheet cake that had coconut topping and she would pour a sugar syrup on the cake and then put the cake under the broiler………. then it hit me! I remembered a recipe that sounded familiar. When I arrived home that night, I looked through her recipes (that were in no particular order) and found a cardboard recipe for an oat cake that looked as if it was taken from a quaker oat box a LONG time ago. So that weekend I decided to give the recipe a try. The next day I took a piece over to my father and he said, as if striking gold, “THAT’S IT!”. He said it took him back to that small mining town that he had grown up in all those many years ago. My curiosity got the better of me so I eventually had to ask him why it was called the “jailhouse cake”? He said “Well, your grandmother and grandfather had belonged to some organization in Athens county. This led them to become good friends with the county sheriff. The sheriffs wife, who lived at the jail, had brought this cake to one of the group functions and your grandmother had asked for the recipe. The sheriffs wife would make it for the prisoners because it was a pretty easy recipe and would feed a good number of people. So every time your grandmother would make this cake we would all call it the “jailhouse cake”. When I make any of my family recipes I usually try to change up the ingredients or add something that I think the recipes are missing to make them better. However, this one is so delicious that I could NOT think of anything to change to make it look or taste better. Now I will say, it may not be the prettiest cake in the world but it is so moist and tender and has an unbelievable cinnamon spice flavor that it is now one of my favorite sheet cakes of all time.

By the way, about a year after I had made this cake for the first time my mother had found a box of recipes from my dads mother. They were in a small green index card box that looked like it had been to war. When I opened the card box for the first time, there was that “jailhouse cake” recipe, and it was in my grandmothers own handwriting. This recipe has become so very special to me and extremely sentimental since she has been gone for such a long time.

Jailhouse Cake

Gather all your ingredients

Jailhouse cake ingredients

Combine boiling water and quick oats let sit 20 minutes

Jailhouse cake oats & water

Cream butter and sugars until light and fluffy

IMG_5516

Add eggs and mix

IMG_5521

Combine dry ingredients and mix just until combined

IMG_5522

Add oat mixture to batter and mix until combined

IMG_5524

Pour in to prepared pan and bake 350 degrees for 35 minutes

IMG_5528

Meanwhile combine topping ingredients in a saucepan

IMG_5534

Bring to boil & boil for 1 minute

IMG_5539

Spread evenly over hot baked cake

IMG_5546

Place under broiler 5 minutes

IMG_5549

let cool completely before serving.

Now I know this may not be the most beautiful cake you’ve every seen, especially after you remove it from the oven, but trust me once you cut into it and taste all the warm cinnamon flavor and the wonderful caramel coconut topping I’m sure this will become one of your favorite cakes  as it is one of mine. Enjoy

IMG_5551

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Filed Under: Cakes

Primary Sidebar

Pages

  • Bio
    • About
  • HELLO WORLD!

Recent Posts

  • BBQ Beef Patties
  • Fettuccine Toss
  • Coffee Cake
  • Johnny Marzetti
  • Banana Nut Bread (basic recipe)

Recipes

Archives

Recent Comments

  • simplyoldthymerecipes@gmail.com on Johnny Marzetti
  • Greg Gorton on Johnny Marzetti

Meta

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org

Please follow & like us :)

RSS
Follow by Email
Facebook
fb-share-icon
Twitter
Post on X
Pinterest
fb-share-icon
Get new posts by email

Copyright © 2026 · by Shay Bocks · Built on the Genesis Framework · Powered by WordPress